ABSTRACT
The antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of bacterial isolates from patients with urinary catheter at Federal Medical Center, Umuahia, Abia state, of Nigeria was studied. A total of 33 catheter urine samples were collected from patients admitted at Federal Medical Center, Umuahia. Samples collected were cultured on MacConkey agar and Cystein Lactose Electrolyte Deficient (CLED) agar using the streaking method. Pure colonies of isolate were biochemically characterized, identified and the antibiotic susceptibility test performed using Muller Hinton agar. Out of the 33 samples analyzed, 21 (63.64%) produced significant growth with 23 microbial isolates. The bacterial isolates included E. coil 8 (34.70%), followed by Pseudomnas aeruginosa 5 (21.74%), Klebsiella sp 4(17.39%), Staphylococcus aureus 3 (13.04%) and Proteus mirabilis 3 (13.04%). The isolates showed high resistance to commonly used antibiotics such as ampicillin (100%), tetracycline (95.65%), augumentin (91.30%), cotrimaxole (91.30%), gentamycin (82.61%) and nalixidic acid (82.61%). Intermediate level of resistance was found against ofloxacin (69.57%) and perfloxacin (60.87%). Only nitrofurantoin and ciprofloxacin (56.52% and 43.48% sensitivity respectively) appeared most effective. Therefore, treatment of patients with catheter associated urinary tract infection in this institution should be guided by the result of susceptibility test of isolates and based on doctor’s prescription so as to reduce the incidence of multiple-resistance.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title
Page i
Certification ii
Dedication iii
Acknowledgements iv
Table
of Contents v
List
of Tables vi
Abstract vii
CHAPTER
ONE
1.0
Introduction and
literature Review 1
1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 Aims
and Objectives 2
1.3 Literature Review 3
1.3.1 Description
of Catheter and Types of Urinary Tract Infection 3
1.3.2 Etiologic Agents of Urinary Tract Infection 5
1.3.3 Epidemiology and Risk Factors 6
1.3.4 Pathogenesis of Infection 7
1.3.5 Virulence Factors 8
1.3.6 Clinical Features 9
CHAPTER TWO
2.0
Materials and Methods
11
2.1. Study Area and Population
11
2.2 Specimen Collection 11
2.3 Preparation of Culture Media
11
2.4 Microscopy, Culture and Identification of
Isolates
11
2.4.1 Gram Staining
12
2.4.2 Biochemical Analysis
12-16
2.5 Antibiotic Sensitivity Test
16
CHAPTER
THREE
3.0 Results 18-25
CHAPTER
FOUR
4.1 Discussion
26-27
4.2 Conclusion
28
References
Appendix
LIST
OF TABLES
Tables
|
Title
|
Pages
|
1.
|
Antimicrobial
Agents Used For Antibiotics Susceptibility Test
|
17
|
2.
|
Age And Sex
Distribution of Patient on Indwelling
Urethral Catheter
at Federal Medical Center, Umuahia
|
20
|
3.
|
Length of
Catheterization in Relation to Development
of Significant
Bacteriuria
|
21
|
4.
|
Indication for
Indwelling Catheterization in Relation to Length of Catheterization Among
Patients at Federal
Medical Center,
Umuahia
|
22
|
5.
|
Morphological,
Cultural and Biochemical
Characteristics of
Bacterial Isolates
|
23
|
6.
|
Microbial Isolates
and their Distribution in Relation
to Gender from Patients with Indwelling
Urinary
Catheter
|
24
|
7.
|
Antimicrobial
Susceptibility Patterns of Bacterial
Isolates from
Patients with Indwelling Urinary
Catheter
|
25
|
|
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 INTRODUCTION
AND LITERATURE REVIEW
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The
urinary tract is the most common site of nosocomial infection accounting for
more than 40% of the total number reported by acute care hospitals and affecting
approximately 600,000 patients per year (CDC, 2009; Meers 1988; Warren 1997).
Sixty six percent to 86% of these infections usually follow instrumentation of
urinary tract, mainly catheterization (Nicolle 2001).The risk of acquiring a
urinary tract infection (UTI) depends on method and duration of catheterization,
the quality of catheter care and host susceptibility (Kunin and Calvin, 2001).
Reported infection rates vary
widely, ranging from 1% to 5% after a single brief catheterization to virtually
100% for patients with indwelling urethral catheters draining into an open
system for more than 4 days (Saint, 2000). Over 20% of patients catheterized
and maintained on closed drainage on busy hospital wards may be expected to
become infected (Kunin and Calvin 2001). Host factors which appear to increase
the risk of acquiring catheter associated UTI include advanced age, debilitating
and the post partum state (Mino et al.,
1997)
Catheter – associated UTI are caused
by a variety of pathogens including Escherichia
coli, Klebsiella species, Proteus
species, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Enterococcus species, Staphylococcus species and Serratia. Many of these microorganisms
are part of the patient’s endogenous bowel flora but they can also be acquired
by cross – contamination from other patients or hospital personnel or by exposure
to contaminated solution or non – sterile equipments (Kunin and Calvin, 2001).
Catheter–Associated Urinary Tract
Infection (CAUTI) in healthy patients is often asymptomatic and is likely to
resolve spontaneously with the removal of the catheter. Occasionally, infection
persists and leads to such complications as prostatitis, epididymitis, cystitis,
pyelonephiritis and gram–negative bacteraemia particularly in high risk
patients (Kunin and Calvin 2001).
The
last complication is serious since
it is associated with a significant mortality, but fortunately occurs in less
than 1% of catherization patients (Kregar
et al., 1980).
Although community acquired UTI has
been well investigated in different groups of patients in Nigeria ( Odutaola et al; 1998; Ekweozor and Onyemenem 1996),
only few studies(Oni et al; 2003;
Taiwo and Aderounmu, 2006) have investigated and documented the etiological
agents of catheter- associated UTI of or their susceptibility pattern to
antimicrobial agents. In places where little have been done , the problem of
under reporting same result about the catheter associated related infection may bring about excessive and indiscriminate
consumption of broad spectrum and higher antimicrobial compound, contributing
to the problem of bacterial resistance occurring in the association with
catheterization and susceptibility pattern.
1.2 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
1. To
isolate the common bacterial pathogens in patients with urinary catheter,
2. To identify the bacterial pathogens, and,
3. To
determine their antimicrobial susceptibility pattern as this will provide information
on the best choice of antibiotic to be useful for treatment of urinary catheter
infection in the study area.
1.3 LITERATURE REVIEW
A
broad review of literature about urinary catheter in relation to urinary tract
infection has been carried out to identify major areas of research and gaps in
knowledge. Some of them are discussed
below.
1.3.1 DESCRIPTION OF CATHETER AND TYPES OF URINARY
TRACT INFECTION
Catheter
is a tube that can be inserted into a body cavity, duct or vessel thereby
allowing drainage, injection of fluids, or accesses surgical instruments (Tebbs
and Elliott, 1994). The process of inserting a catheter is called
catheterization. In most uses, a catheter is a thin, flexible tube (“soft”
catheter), though in some uses, it is larger and solid (“hard”). A catheter
left inside the body, either temporarily or permanently may be referred to as
an indwelling catheter and may remain in a patient for many days or weeks. Where
the catheter is temporarily inserted into the bladder and removed once the
bladder is emptied, it is known as an intermittent catheter. Catheters are extensively used in urology and
are made of variety of materials, shapes and sizes. Two main group of catheter
used in urology are urethral catheter and supra public catheter. Urethral
catheter is a drainage tube inserted into the bladder by passing it through the
urethra, the natural tube that leads from the bladder to the outside, while the
suprapublic catheter is a urinary catheter inserted into the bladder through the
abdominal wall (Wadhaw, 2002). Optimal use of catheter with minimal chances of
infection, allergy, or irritation requires that catheters have certain
characteristics that play an important role in their use, application and
acceptance by some patients (Tebbs and Elliott, 1994). Some of the key
characteristics of catheter are listed below:
1. Flexibility:
catheters should have the ability to maneuver and travel through curved blood vessels
or cavities.
2. Durability:
ability to exist for a long duration while sustaining pressure and liquid flow.
3. Chemical Compatibility:
compatibility to prevent adverse reactions against body tissues, medications
and fluids.
4. Biocompatibility:
ability to be accepted by the body without infection or allergic reactions.
5. Thromboresistance
Designed: should be designed to prevent clotting of
blood.
6. Radiopaque:
a catheter should have the ability to be tracked during fluoroscopic
visualization.
7. Kink-Resistant Designed:
should be designed to prevent clogging and repture and ensure smooth travel
through the vessels or cavity
8. Non-Carcinogenic:
low tendency to cause neoplasia (cancer)
9. Should
be able to resist microbial adhesion and biofilm deposition
10. Should be able to accept surface coating (e.g.
hydrogel, antithrombotic, antibacterial) (Colas and Curtis, 2004; Brown, 1995, Tebbs
and Elliot, 1994).
Primary
and recurrent urinary tract infections are classified depending whether they
are first infection or repeated event, complicated and uncomplicated depending
on the factors that trigger infections. Complicated infections as often in men than
women, and occur as a result of some anatomical or structural abnormalities
such as bladder and kidney dysfunction. Uncomplicated infections are associated
with bacterial infection and affect mostly women than men. Urinary tract
infection can involve mucosal tissue (cystitis) or soft tissue (pyelonephritis,
prostatitis). Anatomically, the infection can be limited to the lower urinary
tract (urethritis, cystitis and prostatitis) and the upper urinary tract (pyelonephritis) (Evans
et al., 1982).
1.3.3 ETIOLOGIC AGENTS OF UTI
Urinary
tract infections (UTI) are a bacterial infection of the urinary system which
consists of the kidney, ureter, bladder and urethra. Many different organisms
can infect the urinary tract but by far the most common agents are the
gram-negetive bacilli (Braunwald et al.,
2001; Wilson and Gaido, 2004). E.coli
is the primary cause of uncomplicated infections of the urinary tract including
cystitis (Gunther et al., 2001; Sahm et al; 2001). According to an
international survey of the antimicrobial susceptibility of pathogens from uncomplicated UTIs, E.coli accounts for 77.0% of isolates (Kahlmeter,
2003). However, there is some evidence that the percentage of UTIs caused by E.coli is decreasing being replaced by
other members of the Enterobacteriaceae
(Haryniewicz et al, 2001; Weber et a.l, 1997).
On
the other hand, another literature by Braunwald et al.,(2001) indicated that other gram negative rods, especially Proteus and Klebsiella and occasionally Enterobacter,
account for a smaller proportion of uncomplicated infections. These organisms
plus Serratia and Pseudomonas, assume increasing importance in recurrent infections,
associated with urologic manipulation, calculi, or obstruction.
Gram
positive cocci were isolated more frequently from a hospital setting and the most
common were Enterococcus species (Wilson
and Gaido, 2004; Haryniwicz et al.,
2001). Staphylococcus saprophyticus –
norobiocin –resistant, coagulase – negative species accounts for 10 to 15% of
acute symptomatic UTIs in young females. More commonly, Enterococci and Staphylococcus
aureus cause infections in patients
with renal stones or previous instrumentation or surgery. Isolation of S. aureus from the urine should arouse suspicion
of bacteremic infection of the kidney (Braunwald et al., 2001).
E.coli, K.pneumoniae, C.
freundii, Proteus, Pseudomonas, Serratia,
Coagulase-negative Staphylococcus, Candida
albicans are species implicated in catheter- associated urinary tract
infection (Braunwald et al., 2001; Oni
et
al, 2003; Taiwo and Aderounmu, 2006).
1.3.4 EPIDEMIOLOGY AND RISK FACTORS
Urinary
tract infection occurs in every age and in both genders. Women have a higher
risk of developing a urinary tract infection than men (Colgan and William, 2011).
In women, the tube through which urine travels (urethra) is very short and
empties very close to the vaginal opening. Therefore, it is easier for bacteria
from the vagina to travel to the urethra and then to the bladder, causing acute
cystitis. By contrast, men have a longer urethra which makes it harder for
bacteria to travel and settle in the bladder. Antibacterial prostatic secretion
also lessens the likelihood of men developing urinary tract infections.
Additionally, there is only a narrow band of flesh (the perineum) between the
anus and vagina in woman; therefore it is easy for bacteria to move from the
anus to the vagina and from there to the urethra and the bladder (Salvatore et al., 2011). A man’s risk for urinary
tract infection increases with age. Older men are more likely to experience prostate
related problem that could lead to UTI. Children are also prone to UTI .However,
estimate of frequency among children vary widely. In a group of children with a
fever, ranging in age between birth and two years, two to 20% were diagnosed of
a UTI (Bhat et al
., 2011).
The
epidemiology of UTI is influenced by the pathophysiology of the infections as
well as the virulence of the isolates and the immune status of the host. The
predisposing factors frequently associated with UTI include: diabetes,
uncircumcision, pregnancy, indwelling or intermittent bladder catheterization,
urinary tract instrumentation, sexual activity. The non specific factors that
can significantly enhance either directly or indirectly the virulence of
bacteria are the birth control pill, alcohols, smoking and antibiotics.
Hospitalized patients develop UTI more frequently than out patients (CDC 2009;
Meers 1988; Warren 1997).
1.3.5 PATHOGENESIS OF INFECTION
In
the vast majority of UTIs bacteria gain access to the bladder through the
urethra. Ascent of bacteria from the bladder may follow and is probably the
pathway for most renal parenchymal infections. The female urethra appears to be
particularly prone to colonization with colonic gram negative bacilli because
of its proximity to the anus, its short length (about 4cm) and its termination beneath
the labia. Sexual intercourse causes the introduction of bacteria into the
bladder and is temporally associated with the onset of cystitis; it thus
appears to be important in the pathogenesis of UTIs in younger women. In
addition, use of spermicidal coated condoms dramatically alters the normal
bacterial flora and has been associated with marked increases in vaginal
colonization with E.coli
Infection
of the renal parenchyma by many species of gram positive (particularly in
patients with Staphylococcal
bacteremia) clearly occurs by the hematogenous route. Increased pressure on the
bladder can cause lymphatic flow to be directed to the kidney. However,
evidence for a significant role for renal lymphatic in the pathogenesis of
pyelonephritis is unimpressive. The invasion of bacteria to the bladder through
the urethra is of paramount importance in the pathogenis of UTI, while the
hematogenous route offers a less frequent but significant pathway (Connie et al., 1995).
1.3.6 VIRULENCE FACTORS
All
uropathogens are equipped with a variety of virulence factors. The best
characterized are those from E. coli (Oelschaeger
et al., 2002). However, not all
strains of E. coli are equally
capable of infecting the intact urinary tract. Bacterial virulence factors markedly
influence the likelihood that a given strain, once introduced into the bladder
will cause UTI. Among the first vurulence factors that come into play during
establishment of a urinary tract infection are adhesins (Oelchlaegar et al., 2002). E. coli which infects and causes diseases of the urinary tracts
expresses several adherence factors including type 1 and P fimbriae (Connel et al., 2002) .Type 1 fimbriea are hair
like projections that extends from the
surface of E. coli and other genera
of the enterobacteriaceae (Gunther et
al ., 2001). These fimbriae bind mannose – containing oligosaccharides via
the Fim H adhesive tip protein and are required for colonization of the urinary
tract by uropathogenic E.coli. Besides their primary function
as adhesion molecules, several other additional functions can now be attributed
to these organelles. They may also function as invasins, promote biofilm
formation and transmit signals to epithelial cells resulting in inflammation (Oelsachaeger
et al., 2002).
In
addition, uropathogenic E.coli
strains usually produce hemolysin and aerobactin (a siderophore for scavenging
iron) and are resistant to the bactericidal action of human serum. Nearly all E.coli strains causing acute
pyelonephritis and most of those causing acute cystitis are uropathogenic. In
contrast, infections in patients with structural or functional abnormalities of
the urinary tract are generally caused by bacterial strain that lack those uropathogenic
properties; the implication is that these properties are not needed for
infection of the damaged urinary tract (Braunwald
et al, 2001).
1.3.7 CLINICAL FEATURES
Urinary
tract infections have traditionally been viewed as acute and often self limiting
infections. However, this concept has been challenged by recent findings
demonstrating that an acute bladder infection results from a complex series of
host pathogen interactions that can lead to bacterial invasion and persistence
and that ultimately can determine the cause of the infectious disease
(Schilling et al., 2001). In general,
UTIs can be classified as asymptomatic bacteriuria, cystitis, or acute
pyelonephritis. Cystitis predominantly involves colonization of the bladder (Gunther
et al., 2001).
Patients
with cystitis usually report dysuria, frequency, supra pubic pain. The urine
often becomes cloudy and malodorous, and it is bloody in about 30% of cases.
White blood cells and bacteria can be detected by examination of unspun urine
in most cases. However, some women with cystitis have only 102 to 104
bacteria per milliliter of urine, and in these instances bacteria cannot be
seen in a Gram stained preparation. Physical examination generally reveals only
tenderness of the suprapublic area (Braunwald et al., 2001).
The
more severe upper urinary tract disease acute pyelonephritis involves
colonization of the kidneys and represents an infection capable of progressing
to bacteremia (Gunther et al., 2001).
Symptoms of acute pyelonephritis generally develop rapidly over a few hours or
a day and include fever, chills, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea. Symptoms of
cystitis may or may not be present. Besides fever, tachycardia and generalized
muscle tenderness, physical examination reveals marked tenderness on deep
pressure in one or both costovertebral angles. Most patients have significant
leukocytosis and bacteria detectable in Gram-stained unspun urine. Hematuria
may be demonstrated during the acute phase of the disease; if it persists after
acute manifestation of infection have subsided, a stone, a tumor, or tuberculosis
should be considered (Braunwald et al.,
2001).
Most
catheter associated bacteriurias are asymptomatic (Warren 1997). Two studies of
hospitalized patients with catheter related UTI found that the majority were
asymptomatic, and that patients with and without UTI did not differ in signs
and symptoms of fever, dysuria, urgency, and flank pain. Importantly, patient’s
report of UTI symptoms, fever, and elevated plasma white blood cell count did
not predict catheter-associated UTI (CAUTI).
Urinary
white blood cell count was the best predictor of CAUTI (Medigan and Neff, 2013).
The complications in short-term catherized patients include fever, acute
pyelonephritis, bacteremia and death; patient with long term catheters in place
are at risk for these complications and catheter obstruction, urinary tract
stones, local periurinary infections, chronic renal inflammations, chronic pyelonephritis,
and over years bladder cancer (Warren, 1997).
Login To Comment