ABSTRACT
This study investigated the isolation of microorganisms from used and unused engine oil samples. The major bacterial isolates from the engine oil samples belong to Bacillus sp., Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas sp. respectively, whereas the fungal isolates includes Aspergillus niger, Aspergillus flavus, and Penicillium sp. The total heterotrophic plate count (THPC) for the used and unused engine oils ranged from 1.4 × 105cfu/ml to 4.4 × 105cfu/ml. The total coliform plate count (TCPC) of the used and unused engine oils ranged from 1.4 × 105cfu/ml to 4.1 × 105cfu/ml. The total fungal plate count (TFPC) of the used and unused engine oils ranged from 1.5 × 105cfu/ml to 4.0 × 105cfu/ml.It was observed that Pseudomonas sp. is the most frequently occurring bacteria isolate with a percentage occurrence of (35.0%) whereas Escherichia coli had the least percentage occurrence of (10.0%). Aspergillus niger is the most frequently occurring fungal isolate with a percentage occurrence of (41.7%) whereas Aspergillus flavus has the least percentage occurrence of (25.0%). Finding feasibility in utilization of engine oil by microbial groups revealed that the isolates utilized these oily materials. The isolates showed different degrees of turbidity with the highest turbidity showed in the used engine oil sample for some of the tested strains. Engine oils are prone to deterioration when they are exposed to microbial activities, especially when they are in-use as shown from the study. Therefore microbial growths are proxies for deterioration in engine oils. The introduction of preservatives, additives and biocides in the engine oil could prevent microorganisms from infesting the engine oil thereby increasing its shelf life and preventing the engine parts from touching each other.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page i
Certification iii
Dedication iv
Acknowledgement v
Table of Contents vi
List of Tables ix
Abstract x
1.0 CHAPTER ONE 1
1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 Types
of Engine Oil 2
1.3 Advantages
of Engine Oil 4
1.4 Disadvantages
of Engine Oil 5
1.5 Factors
Influencing Engine Oil Biodeterioration 7
1.6 Aims
and Objectives 11
2.0 CHAPTER TWO 12
2.1 Literature
Review 12
2.1.1 Assessment of Bacterial and Fungal
Deteriogens of Selected Lubricating
Oils Used In
Industrial Generators 12
2.1.2 Biodegradation of Used Engine Oil Using Mixed
and Isolated Cultures 14
2.1.3 A Comparative Study of Oil Degradation with
Used and Unused Engine
Oil by
Microbes Isolated from Water Sample of Mechanic Workshops 16
2.2 Microorganisms
Responsible For Engine Oil Biodeterioration 18
2.2.1 Aerobic
microorganisms 18
2.2.2 Anaerobic
microorganisms 19
3.0 CHAPTER THREE 20
3.1 Materials
and Method 20
3.2 Study
Area 20
3.3 Collection
of Samples 20
3.4 Sterilization
of Materials 20
3.5 Preparation
of Culture Media 21
3.6 Culturing of Used and Unused Engine Oil
Samples 21
3.7 Inoculation
and Isolation 21
3.8 Purification of Isolates 21
3.9 Identification
of Bacterial Isolates 22
3.9.1 Gram Staining 22
3.9.2 Biochemical
Test 22
3.9.2.1 Indole test 22
3.9.2.2
Methyl red (MR) 23
3.9.2.3 Voges proskauer (VP) 23
3.9.2.4 Hydrogen sulphide test (H2S) 23
3.9.2.5 Citrate test 23
3.9.2.6 Urease test 24
3.9.2.7 Catalase test 24
3.9.2.8 Coagulase test 24
3.9.2.9 Sugar fermentation test 24
3.9.2.10 Starch test 25
3.10 Identification
of Fungal Isolates 25
3.11 Growth of the Mixed Culture of the
Bacterial and Fungal isolates in the
Engine Oil 25
4.0 CHAPTER FOUR 27
4.1 Results 27
5.0 CHAPTER FIVE 42
5.1 Discussion,
Conclusion and Recommendation 42
5.1.1 Discussion 42
5.1.2 Conclusion 46
5.1.3 Recommendation 46
References 47
Appendix 51
LIST OF TABLES
Table
|
Title
|
Page
No
|
1
|
Mean microbial count from the used and
unused engine oil samples
|
29
|
2
|
Morphological
identification, Biochemical
Identification, Gram Reaction and sugar utilization Profile of bacterial
isolates used and unused engine oil samples
|
30
|
3
|
Cultural Morphology
and Microscopic Characteristics of the Fungal Isolates from used and unused engine oil samples
|
31
|
4
|
Percentage occurrence of the bacterial isolates
from the used engine oil samples
|
32
|
5
6
7
|
Percentage occurrence of the bacterial
isolates from the unused engine oil samples
Percentage occurrence of the Fungal
isolates from the used engine oil samples
Percentage occurrence of the Fungal
isolates from the unused engine oil samples
|
33
34
35
|
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure
|
Title
|
Page No
|
1
|
A graph of Total viable count, pH, and OD
of mixed bacterial (Bacillus sp., S. aureus and Pseudomonas sp.)
colonies from used engine oil against time
|
35
|
2
|
A graph of Total viable count, pH, and OD of
mixed bacterial (Bacillus sp., S. aureus and Pseudomonas sp.)
colonies from unused engine oil against time
|
36
|
3
|
A graph of Total viable count, pH, and OD
of mixed fungal (A. niger, A. flavus and Penicillium sp.)
colonies from used engine oil against time
|
37
|
4
|
A graph of Total viable count, pH, and OD
of mixed fungal (A. niger, A. flavus and Penicillium sp.)
colonies from unused engine oil against time
|
38
|
5
|
A graph of pH and optical density of mixed
bacterial and fungal colonies from used engine oil
|
39
|
6
|
A graph of pH and optical density of mixed
bacterial and fungal colonies from unused engine oil
|
40
|
1.0 CHAPTER
ONE
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Engine oil is a substance comprising base oils enhanced with particularly antiwear additive plus detergents, dispersants and, for multi-grade oils viscosity
index improvers. Engine oil is used for lubrication of internal
combustion engines. The main function of Engine
oil is to reduce friction and wear on moving parts and to clean the engine from sludge (one of
the functions of dispersants) and varnish (detergents). It also
neutralizes acids that originate from fuel and from oxidation of the lubricant (detergents), improves sealing of piston
rings, and cools the engine by carrying heat away from moving parts (Miller et al., 2005).
Unused engine oil is a complex mixture of hydrocarbons and other organic
compounds, including some organo metallic constituents that are used to
lubricate the parts of an automobiles engine, in order to keep everything
running smoothly while used engine oil contains more metals and heavy
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) that would contribute to chronic
hazards including mutagenicity and carcinogenicity. In addition, polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) have a widespread occurrence in various ecosystems
that contribute to the persistence of these compounds in the environment (Van-Hamme et al., 2003). The illegal dumping
of used motor oil is an environmental hazard with global ramifications (Blodgette, 2001).
Engine oil is a lubricant used in internal combustion engines, which
power engine-generators, and many other machines. In engines, there
are parts which move against each other, and the friction wastes otherwise useful power by converting the kinetic energy to heat. It also wears away those parts, which could lead to lower efficiency
and degradation of the engine. This increases fuel consumption and decreases
power output and can lead to engine failure.
Engine
oil creates a separating film between surfaces of adjacent moving parts to
minimize direct contact between them,
decreasing heat caused by friction and
reducing wear, thus protecting the engine. In use, engine oil transfers
heat through conduction as it flows through the engine. In an engine
with a recirculating oil pump, this heat is transferred by means of airflow
over the exterior surface of the [oil pan], airflow through an oil cooler and
through oil gases evacuated by the Positive
Crankcase Ventilation (PCV) system. While modern recirculating pumps are typically provided
in passenger cars and other engines similar or larger in size, total
loss oiling is a design option that remains popular in small and miniature engines.
Coating
metal parts with oil also keeps them from being exposed to oxygen, inhibiting oxidation at elevated operating
temperatures preventing rust or corrosion. Corrosion
inhibitors may also be added to the motor oil. Many motor oils also have detergents and dispersants added to help keep the engine clean and
minimize oil sludge build-up. The oil is able to trap soot from
combustion in itself, rather than leaving it deposited on the internal surfaces.
It is a combination of this, and some singeing that turns used oil black after
some running. Engine oil may also serve as a cooling agent. In some
constructions, oil is sprayed through a nozzle inside the crankcase onto the
piston to provide cooling of specific parts that undergo high-temperature
strain. On the other hand, the thermal
capacity of
the oil pool has to be filled, i.e. the oil has to reach its designed
temperature range before it can protect the engine under high load.
1.2 TYPES OF ENGINE OIL
Determining the type of engine oil for your
generator whether synthetic, synthetic blend, high-mileage or conventional oil,
depends on several factors. Some are external factors, such as the climate you
live in, your driving habits, or even the age of your engine. Other factors are
fixed based on your generator's engine type and the manufacturer's
specifications.
· Full
Synthetic Engine Oil
Full synthetic oil is
ideal for generators that demand peak level performance and high levels of
lubrication. Full synthetic oil provides higher viscosity levels, resistance to
oxidation and thermal breakdown, and helps fight against oil sludge. Plus, it
helps improve fuel efficiency and can even increase a generator’s horsepower by
reducing engine drag (Miller et al., 2005).
Because synthetic generator oil can cost two to four times more than regular
oil, talk to your technician about whether it’s the right oil for your generator.
If you live in a climate with super cold winters or very hot summers, synthetic
oil may be the best type of oil for your generator. Older engines could also
benefit from synthetic oil, as it can help prevent harmful sludge build-up that
some older engines seem to be prone to.
· Synthetic
Blend Engine Oil
Synthetic blend oil
offers the best of both worlds. It has many of the characteristics of full
synthetic oil, but at a much lower price. This type of oil is a mixture of
synthetic and conventional base oils, plus some additives, for extra resistance
to oxidation and excellent low-temperature properties. Synthetic blends make it
easy for generator users to make the switch from conventional to synthetic oil,
which is why this type of engine oil is becoming increasingly popular among
today’s savviest users. It’s also a great middle ground for generator users who
want the added protection and performance of synthetic oil, but might not be
ready to foot the bill for a total switch to full synthetic oil.
· Conventional
Engine Oil
Conventional oil is
the most commonly used type of engine oil. It is ideal for light-duty,
late-model generators with low to average mileage and a simple engine design.
· High
Mileage Engine Oil
High mileage engine oil is
specifically designed for cars with more than 75,000 miles. This type of oil
can help reduce oil consumption, minimize leaks and oil seepage, and can also
help reduce smoke and emissions in older engines.
1.3 ADVANTAGES OF ENGINE OIL
When it comes to longer and healthier life of
your generator engine, engine oil plays a vital role in it. High quality oil is
important and a fundamental characteristic of your generator depends on it like
smooth running, fuel efficiency, performance and emissions. Below are the major
advantages of good engine oil (both Synthetic and Mineral) for your generator.
·
Better
Lubrication
Engine Oil’s first and foremost task is to
lubricate the running parts, the engine components are exposed to grueling
temperatures and are tend to gradual wear and tear. However, having a good
engine oil and timely change helps in appropriate lubrication of parts and
in-turn smooth and quieter running of the engine.
·
Cleaner
Engine
Apart from lubrication, engine oil also clean
internals of your generator engine; as mentioned above, working engine parts
are susceptible to wear and tear. The microscopic debris and particles are
removed by the oils and stops them from building up. But over the time, engine
oil will get dirty and will not work as indicated. In a nutshell, timely change
is immensely important along with the oil filter. And as these oils come with
extra additives, it helps in working as detergents in the cleaning activity.
So, higher the quality of oil, the cleaner your engine will be.
·
Improved
Fuel Efficiency and Performance
As engine oils helps in keeping the engine
clean and in top nick, the generator extracts the best fuel efficiency as
marketed by the respective automaker. However, the same things also apply here,
regular and cheap oil might fulfill the purpose but your generator can't really
benefit from the good stuff. Moreover, smoother running of the engine and
cleaner internals also maximizes the mechanical output of the generator.
·
Maximum
Engine Life
Engine’s life is no where less nowadays
compared to yesteryears, but they are rather plagued with wear and tear. But
having a good engine oils helps in maximizing the life of your engine. As with
better additives, it helps in minimizing the sludge and keeps the internals
clean and well lubricated.
·
Lower
Engine Emissions
Emission
norms are getting strict day by day and engine oils keeps the generator running
in healthy state and in-turn, a cleaner exhaust. Moreover, older generators
sometimes burn the dirty oil, causing an excess of harmful engine emissions.
Fresh and good engine oil is less likely to burn and has better ability to
absorb particles and engine by-product emissions, making your generator pollute
much less.
1.4 DISADVANTAGES OF ENGINE
OIL
Due to its chemical composition, worldwide
dispersion and effects on the environment, used engine oil is considered a
serious environmental problem. Most current engine oil lubricants contain
petroleum base stocks, which are toxic to the environment and difficult to
dispose of after use. Toxic effects of used engine oil on freshwater and marine
organisms vary, but significant long-term effects have been found at
concentrations of 310 ppm in several freshwater fish species and as low as 1
ppm in marine life forms (Vijayendran, 2014). Engine oil can have
an incredibly detrimental effect on the environment, particularly to plants
that depend on healthy soil to grow. There are some ways in which engine oil
affects humans and plants:
·
Contaminating water supplies, contaminating soil, and poisoning plants.
·
Used engine oil dumped on land reduces soil productivity.
·
Improperly disposed used oil ends up in landfills, sewers, backyards, or
storm drains where soil, groundwater and drinking water may be contaminated (Vijayendran,
2014).
The consumption of engine oil in Nigeria has
been on the increase in recent years due to the upsurge in the number of
vehicles, power plants, and generators that make use of these lubricants
(Odjegba and Atebe, 2007). This directly affects the rate at which spent engine
oil enters and pollutes the environment. The indiscriminate disposal of this
waste oil increases pollution incidents in the environment (Odjegba and Atebe,
2007). Some of the pollution effects of used oil in the environment include:
reduction in oxygen supply to microorganisms, pollution of ground and surface
waters and accumulation of metal ions which are toxic to plant. Bioremediation
process is a microorganism mediated transformation or degradation of
contaminants into non-hazardous or less hazardous substances. It is an
attractive approach for cleaning up of hydrocarbons from environment because it
is a simple technique, easy to maintain, applicable over large areas, cost
effective and leads to complete destruction of the contaminant (Achal et al., 2011). Main reason for this
concept is that the majority of the molecules in engine oil are biodegradable.
Many physical, chemical and environmental factors like temperature, nutrients,
oxygen, biodegradability, photoxidation, bioavailability, soil moisture, soil
acidity and alkalinity etc. affect the process of biodegradation of
hydrocarbons (Rahman et al., 2003).
Bacteria and fungi are known to be the
principal agents of biodegradation of hydrocarbons. Fungi have a higher
tolerance to the toxicity of hydrocarbons due to their physiology and
adaptation to such variations in the environment and have the mechanism for the
elimination of spilled oil from the environment. Fungi have been found to be
better degraders of petroleum than traditional bioremediation techniques with
bacteria (Ojo, 2005). Fungi have also demonstrated the ability to degrade and
mineralize phenols, halogenated phenolic compounds, petroleum hydrocarbons,
polycyclic aromatic compounds and polychlorinatedbiphenyls. Many researchers
studied the role of fungi in biodegradation process of petroleum products and
the most common fungi which have been recorded as biodegraders belong to the
following genera: Alternaria, Aspergillus, Candida, Cephalosporium,
Cladosporium, Fusarium, Geotrichum, Gliocladium, Mucor, Pleurotus,
Paecilomyces, Penicillium, Polyporus, Rhizopus, Rhodotorula, Saccharomyces,
Talaromyces and Torulopsis (Adekunle and Adebambo, 2007). The advantages
associated with fungal bioremediation are primarily in the versatility of the
technology and its cost efficiency compared to other remediation technologies
such as incineration, thermal desorption and extraction. The use of fungi is
expected to be relatively economical as they can be grown on a number of
inexpensive agricultural or forest wastes such as corncobs and sawdust. More
so, their utilization is a gentle non-aggressive approach. Increased
proliferation of automobile workshops within Nigeria has contributed markedly
to the problem of soil contamination and this has resulted in the concomitant
exposure of the surrounding soil within the vicinity of these workshops to high
levels of spent engine oil and lubricating oils.
1.5 FACTORS INFLUENCING
ENGINE OIL BIODETERIORATION
The composition of engine oil, the presence
of accessible forms of nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, magnesium, other
micro-elements and water as well as other environmental conditions such as
temperature, pH and oxygen modulate microbial growth and thus biofouling
processes. As a general rule, all the listed chemical species are present
either in the oil or in the accompanying water phase including the water
dissolved in the oil.
·
Temperature
Microorganisms promoting fouling of engine
oil can live in a wide range of temperatures—from 4 up to 60oC and
above (Chung et al., 2000), The
species variety of Hydrocarbon oxidizing (HCO) microorganisms is highest at
temperatures between 250C and 300C.
·
pH
At pH value from 4 up to 9, however,
microorganisms tend to prefer a neutral pH (Boszczyk-Maleszak et al., 2006).
·
Water content
Microorganisms are capable of surviving at
elevated temperatures and in presence of toxic substances, but are unable to
live without water. It is well known that 1% water is enough for substantial
microbial growth, whereas spores of microorganisms can survive in the presence
of 5–80 ppm of water in fuel system. It is interesting, that for a 1lm size
microorganism, 1 mm layer of water is comparable to a man standing next to 500
m of water. Therefore, a fine film of water on tank surface is enough to allow
microorganisms to start growing, and the cell metabolism, once begun, causes
accumulation of more water. Thus, the important factor limiting growth of
microorganisms in oil is the availability of water. For example, anti-ice fuel
additives such as glycols reduce the availability of water and thus inhibit
growth of microorganisms. Water penetrates into fuel systems with moist air
condensing on cold metal and also with watered fuel, when water is pumped as
ballast into ships (Gardner and Stewart, 2002). Water is heavier than
Hydrocarbon-fuel and consequently it accumulates at the bottom where the
biphasic system ‘‘oil-water’’ supports a growth of microorganisms which can use
oil as a carbon source (Muthukumar, 2003). In addition to the acceleration of
oil biofouling, water, present in fuels, reduces their viscosity and renders
pumps ineffective. Generally, it is extremely difficult to avoid the occurrence
of water in tanks, as it is impossible to avoid the condensation phenomenon
under conditions of changing temperatures.
·
Oxygen
Oxygen penetrates in storage tanks during
fuel filling, ventilation of tanks, purification and processing of Hydrocarbon
(HC) raw material. Oxygen can (photo) chemically reacts with Hydrocarbons (HCs)
of oil and oil products with formation of coloured particles, pitches and
water. Moreover, oxygen being a terminal electron acceptor for aerobic
microorganisms directly contributes to microbial growth. A variety of
microorganisms carrying out the decomposition of Hydrocarbons (HCs), the
formation of slime, biofilms and insoluble particles, are aerobic. The rate of
microbial Hydrocarbon (HC) oxidation obviously increases with an increase of
aeration but, even at concentration of oxygen as low as 0.1 mg/l, conversion of
Hydrocarbon (HC) still occurs (Watanabe et
al., 2002). Moreover, if it would be possible to create completely
anaerobic storage conditions, oil and oil products are not protected against
microbial degradation since many facultative aerobic and anaerobic
microorganisms continue to thrive (Watanabe et
al., 2002;). For example, during the storage of engine oil, Sulphate
reducing bacteria (SRB) consuming Hydrocarbon (HC) and using available sulphate
as electron acceptor actively grows there.
·
Nutrients
The limiting factor of microbial growth is
also an availability of mineral nutrients, for example, phosphates, which are
usually present in fuels in concentrations as low as 1 mg/l. On the contrary,
significant growth of microorganisms has been observed in systems containing
solution of mineral salts, for example, mineralized flooding water to enhance
oil extraction or seawater which is pumped into tankers as ballast. The
especial danger of these waters is related to abundant presence of sulphate
which triggers the growth of Sulphate reducing bacteria (SRB) enhancing
biodeterioration of oil as discussed above. The corrosion caused by
microorganisms in the presence of water promotes a destruction of tank walls
and the influx of metal ions into oil and oil products (Gardner and Stewart,
2002; Muthukumar,, 2003). Thus, corrosion processes may supply metal ions which
are required for the growth of microorganisms.
·
Chemical Composition
The chemical composition of engine oil and
oil products also influences their susceptibility to biodegradation. The so
called light oil, with mainly moderate chain aliphatic Hydrocarbons (HCs) and
low content of aromatic Hydrocarbons (HCs), is more quickly infected by
microorganisms compared to high-aromatic oils. For example, the light petroleum
from Groznensky and Borislavsky oil fields (Caucasus) was heavily affected by
microorganisms within 7–10 days whereas that from Anastasyevsky oilfield
(Western Siberia) with an aromatic content up to 50% remained unaffected during
90 days of its storage under the same conditions. Moreover, during transport of
light oils using pipelines, the intensive growth of microorganisms enhances
sedimentation of paraffin on pipeline walls. Similarly, the so called sour oil
having high sulphur content is more susceptible to microbial infection and
degradation compared to the so called sweet oil with low sulphur content.
Probably, the absence of sulphur deficiency in the former oil promotes its
biofouling. Products of microorganism metabolism in diesel lead to clogging of
fuel nozzles and finally to the breakage of the engine. Solid and liquid
lubricants (technical vaselines, rope and gun oil) made of petroleum
Hydrocarbons (HCs) are readily affected by fungi, mainly mould fungi, and
bacteria during operation and storage in unprotected containers (Eisentraeger et al., 2002). The solid lubricants are
usually contaminated by microorganisms only in a superficial film whereas the
liquid ones are infected along the full layer. Machine oils produced from
petroleum of various oilfields have a different stability to microbial
infection. A variation from 10% to 100% of biofouling was recorded during the
same period of supervision.
Biodegradation of various machine oils
depends on Hydrocarbon (HC) structure, physical properties of processed oil and
manufacture technology. A high concentration of aromatic and/or polar compounds
increases the stability of machine oils. On the contrary, the machine oils
produced from the sour oils are less biostable than those produced from the
sweet oils, by analogy with crude oils. Generally, the biodegradability of
machine oils is an inverse function of kinematical viscosity and refractive
index (Haus et al., 2001, 2003).
1.6 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
This study is therefore, aimed at isolation
and identification of some possible species of microorganisms from used and
unused engine oil.
The objectives are;
1.
To isolate and characterize microorganisms present on used and unused
engine oil.
2.
To determine the percentage occurrence of the isolates.
Login To Comment