Abstract
Accounting
standards improvements have been recognized as a fundamental pillar of many
economic developments aimed at assuring the more effective operation of capital
markets. In the light of this, the implementation of IFRS in the insurance
business is intended to ensure that financial reports are consistent with
global best practices. Regulators and investors have expressed concern about
the decline invalue of publicly traded insurance companies in Nigeria.The major
objective of the study is to investigate the value relevance of compliance with
insurance contracts disclosure (IFRS 4) of listed insurance companies in
Nigeria between 2012 to 2020 using ex-post facto research design. The sample of
15 companies were sampled from the population of 26 insurance companies
publicly traded on the Nigerian Stock Exchange(NSE) as of December 31, 2020.
The study utilized the Ohlson model and robust ordinary least square regression
for as technique for data analysis. The study found that EPS has a positive but
insignificant impact on the share prices of listed insurance firms in Nigeria
using.The share price of listed insurance firms in Nigeria is positively and
significantly affected by their book value. It was also established thatthe
level of IFRS4 Compliance doesmatter with regards to EPS of insurance firms,
while the level of IFRS4 Compliance is found to be important with respect
toBVPS of insurance firms and finally extent of compliance with insurance
contracts disclosure (IFRS 4) has positive andsignificant effect on Share Price
of insurance companies in Nigeria. The study concludes that compliance with
IFRS 4: Insurance Contract is value relevant. Between the two accountingnumbers
– book values and earnings, book values are more value relevant. The report
recommends, among other things, that Management of insurance businesses should
aim toward enhanced IFRS compliance in order to draw more investment into the
industry and boost growth and competitiveness.
LIST
OF ABBREVIATIONS
BVP
-
|
Book Value Per Share
|
CAMA-
|
Companies
and Allied Matters Act
|
EPS
-
|
Earnings Per Share
|
IFRS -
|
International Financial Reporting Standard
|
IDX -
|
Indonesia Stock
Exchange
|
NSE
-
|
Nigerian Stock
Exchange
|
MV -
|
Market Value
|
VR -
|
Value Relevance
|
|
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title
page - - - - -
- - - - - -i
Abstract
- - - - -
- - - - - -ii
List
of abbreviations - - - -
- - - -
- -iii
Table
of contents - - - -
- - - - - -iv
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION
1.1
Background to the study - -
- - - - - -1
1.2
Statement of the Research Problem -
- - - - - -5
1.3
Research Questions - -
- - - - -
- -7
1.4
Objectives of the Study - -
- - - - - -8
1.5
Research Hypotheses - - -
- - - - - -9
1.6
Scope of the Study - -
- - - - -
- -9
1.7 Significance
of the Study - -
- - - -10
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
- -
- - - - -
- - -11
2.2
Conceptual Literature - - -
- - - - - -11
2.2.1
Concept of Value Relevance - -
- - - -
- -11
2.2.2
Concept of Share Price - - -
- - -
- 12
2.2.3
Concept of Earnings per Share -
- - - -
- -13
2.2.4
Concept of Book Value Per Share - - -
- -
- -13
2.2.5 International Financial Reporting
Standards 4 (Insurance Contract)- -14
2.2.6 An Overview of Insurance Industry in
Nigeria and Regulation -16
2.3
Review of Empirical studies - - -
- - -
- -19
2.3.1 VR of
Accounting Information - Earnings and Book Values per Share- -19
2.3.2 IFRS 4 and VR - - - -
- - -
- -25
2.3.3 IFRS and VR
of Accounting Information - - -
-
- -25
2.4
Theoretical Framework - -
- - - - - -38
2.4.1
Signaling theory - - -
- - - -
- -38
2.4.2 Efficient Market Hypothesis - - - - -
- - -40
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1
Introduction - - - -
- - - - - -41
3.2
Research Design - -
- - - - -
- -41
3.3
Population and Sample Size- - - -
- - -
- -41
3.4 Sources and Methods of Data Collection - -
- - - -42
3.4.1
Disclosure Index- - - -
- - -
- -4
3.5
Methods of Data Analysis - -
- - - - - -43
3.6
Model Specification - - -
- - - - - -43
3.7 Variable Definitions and Measurements - -
- - - -44
3.8
Diagnostic Tests - -
- - - - -
- -45
CHAPTER FOUR DATA ANALYSIS AND
INTERPRETATION
4.1
Introduction - - - -
- - - - - -47
4.2
Summary of Descriptive Statistics - -
- - -
- -47
4.3
Result of Robustness Tests - -
- - - - - -50
4.3.1
Normality of Data - - -
- - - -
- -50
4.3.2
Multicollinearity Test - - - -
- - -
- -50
4.3.3:
Heteroscedasticity Test - - -
- - - - -51
4.4
Data Presentation, Analyses and Interpretation - -
- - -52
4.5
Hypothesis Testing - - - -
- - - - -53
4.6
Discussion of Findings - - - -
- - - -55
4.6.1 Earnings
per Share and Market Price per Share -
- - - -55
4.6.2 Book
Value per Share and Market Price per Share - -
- - -56
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1
Summary - - - -
- - - - - -60
5.2
Conclusion - - - -
- - - - - -61
5.3
Recommendations - -
- - - - -
- -63
5.3
Limitations of the study - -
- - - - - -63
5.3 Areas for
further studies - - -
- - - - -64 References
- -
- - - - -
- - -65
Appendices
- -
- - - - -
- - -80
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
to the study
Improvements of accounting standards
have been recognized as a fundamental pillar of many economic developments
aimed at assuring the more effective operation of capital markets. Hence, the
purpose of standardizing financial reporting procedures is to achieve effective
cross-border financial integrationwhich seeks to ensure that every preparer of
financial report follows the same format and language for the benefit of users
globally+.
The adoption of IFRSs has been
upheld as a step toward improving financial reporting procedures and accounting
information in order to promote efficient capital markets (Bolibok,
2014).Accounting information can be generated more effectively if the
fundamental ideas and methodologies to financial reporting are unified. This is
due to the fact that investors desire high-quality accounting data to improve
their confidence in both domestic and international markets (Nobes &
Parker, 2008).
Value Relevance (VR) refers to the
capacity to explain stock market behavior, including stock price response to
information published in firms' financial statements (Alkali & Lode, 2016).
As it significantly helps investors estimate stock prices, the topic of VR of
accounting information is a popular one. VR is the ability of accounting factors,
such as earnings and book values, to influence share market prices (Barizah
& Bakar, 2011).Therefore, the VR concept is explained as the ability of
accounting information to influence stock prices.
In its conceptual framework, the
IASB stated that accounting information can impact users' economic decisions by
allowing them to assess past, current and future developments or confirm or
correct previous assessments. IFRS identifies relevance as one of the key
qualitative features of financial information. Relevant information will be
presumed to influence investment decision-making if it has predictive value,
previous estimates confirmatory value, or both (IASB, 2010). IFRS are expected
to improve investors' confidence in financial information perceived to be more
reliable as they are considered to be a set of high-quality standards. This has
led to fund providers depending more on IFRS-compliant information in investment
decision-making.
The arguments on the need for
international harmonization and uniformity of accounting standards lednations
to yield to the call and adopt IFRS, with Nigeria adopting it in 2012. The adoption led the Nigeria stock exchange
to issue a directive on conformity with the standards as a main requirement for
all firms listed on the stock market. Further, section 333 (1) of the Nigeria's
Companies and Allied Matters Act (2016) requires the form and contents of
corporate entities‟ financial reports to conform with accounting standards
issued by the Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria as an approach of
providing legal support to reinforce their activities. Since its inception, the
new set of standards which aim to improve the quality of financial reporting
has continued to evolve.
One of the most significant
developments in recent decades has been the worldwide increase in public
concern for the insurance industry. Insurance has enabled societies and
individuals to connect more closely than ever before. Insurance is distinct
from other services in that it is sophisticated and involves significant legal
aspects (Rahman, 2017). The insurance industry is vital to the global economy;
insurance companies assist individuals and businesses in transferring
risk;while insurers, like other types of investors, are significant long-term
players (Bayazidi, 2020). This has resulted in a set of financial reporting
requirements protecting the interests of insurance company investors. In
addition, there is an apparent need to improve financial transparency and the
comparability and compliance of insurance businesses' financial reporting
globally (Bayazidi, 2020). The first phase of the standard insurance contract
reporting project was launched in 2001 by the International Accounting
Standards Board (IASB), with the goal of improving the insurance contract
accounting process and addressing the reporting demands of insurance issuing
business units. Under insurance contracts, the product was IFRS 4.
The IASB released IFRS 4 Phase I in
2004, and it went into force in 2005 as a temporary guide to insurance
contracts until IFRS 17 could be implemented with full standards in 2023. In
addition to those covered by other standards, IFRS 4, Insurance Contracts,
consolidates all requirements for disclosure of insurance contracts, including
reinsurance contracts issued and retained by an insurance business. To help
users better understand financial statements, IFRS 4 aims to improve insurers'
financial reporting of insurance contracts and to ensure that insurers disclose
information that provides clarity on the amounts incurred by insurance
contracts in insurers' statements and the amount, timing and future of
insurance contracts(IFRS 4).
.
The National Insurance Commission
(NAICOM)reveals that the Nigerian insurance sector's adoption of IFRS is aimed
at bringing them to a stage where they become a worldwide player and the best
in Africa. Through IFRS, insurance firms‟ activities will be made more
efficient, transparent, safe and in-line with global best practices with the
aim of achieving 15thplace in insurance premiums generation in the
world by year 2020 (Tolu-Kusimo, 2013). Among
the IFRS adopted by Insurance firms, IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts is particularly
peculiar to the insurance industry.
IFRS compliance studies seek to
evaluate the level or scope of companies‟ compliance with requirements of the
accounting standards as disclosed in financial reports(Yiadom & Atsunyo,
2014). The compliance to the standards is seen as the extent to which entities
comply with their requirements – this decides the usefulness of financial
figures in the eyes of investors (Zango, Kamardin & Ishak, 2015). An
entity's level of compliance is seen to be of great importance as it enhances
the quality of accounting information presented in annual reports.
Hence, sufficient compliance with
IFRS is anticipated to improve VR (Alfraih & Alanezi, 2015).
As VR implies the influence of share
value in the stock market by accounting information (Kargin,2013), the level of
compliance with IFRS disclosures is presumed as an additional information that
can be incorporated into the valuation model to see if greater compliance is
valued by investors (Alfaraih, 2009). VR, according to Al-Hogail (2004), is all
about the amount of a company's market value that can be explained by the
accounting information that has been provided. IFRS-based financial
information's perceived high quality may improve satisfying investors'
information need, depending on how well listed companies adhere to them.
The insurance industry is viewed as
one of the pillars of the financial sector as it serves as a central element
for trade and development. It is believed that the industry plays the double
role of risk management and capital formation. However, in Nigeria the insurance
industry faced several challenges, which resulted in the adoption of the first
Insurance Act in 2003 by the National Insurance Commission (NAICOM), which
resulted in an increase in its capital base requirements. Recapitalization
required a minimum capital base of the insurance companies according to the
insurance categories of life insurance covered by N150m, general N200m and
composite and re-insurance insurance to be established at N350m.Persistence of
the issues further led to an amendment in the Act in 2005 which led to consolidation
of most of the firms in 2007 (Etomi & Partners, 2019). Further need to
strengthen the sector again, moved the National Insurance Commission (NAICOM)
to impose new capital requirements which were expected to be implemented in
June 2020. It is assumed that this measure will reduce the registered insurance
firms from 59 firms to 25 due to mergers and acquisitions that may possibly
take place (Czartoryski, 2019).
Despite its apparent importance and
the challenges plaguing it, the Nigerian Insurance Sector remains understudied,
as seen in the review of relevant literature. The VR literature, though
extensive, has relatively focused largely on other sectors. Additionally, of
the studies carried out on the sector, a majority have only examined the VR of
accounting numbers – earnings and equity book values. However, other
information such as those required under IFRS 4 are considered important. Thus,
the significance of the sector and the scarcity of literature examining it
drive the motivation for this study. The study is therefore, motivated to
examine the importance of compliance with IFRS 4 following the challenges of
listed insurance firms in Nigeria and whether variations in extent of
compliance affect VR.
1.2 Statement of the Research Problem
The goal of IFRS in the insurance
industry is to guarantee that all financial reports would adhere to the
international best practice. Although the majority of companies claim that
their financial statements comply with IFRS, the extent of compliance varies
amongst companies.
The
Nigeria's insurance market as being
plagued by lax enforcement and
regulation(PricewaterhouseCoopers,
2015; Osinuga, 2016; Olunuga, 2021). This demonstrates the necessity for the
sector and professional organizations to intensify efforts to address the
issues behind the sector's below normal performance (Oji, 2019). Regulators and
investors have also expressed concern regarding the decline in the value of
publicly traded insurance corporations. The sector's issues were caused by
Nigeria's low insurance coverage, lax regulation, and certain questionable
business practices (Oji, 2018).
Furthermore, IFRS 4; Insurance
Contracts are under pressure from auditors, practitioners, and financial
analysts because it permits insurance companies to calculate their financial
results and positions using outdated metrics and allows them to report profits
even when their insurance coverage has not yet been rendered. Other criticism
centers on the fact that genuine profit drivers are invisible (Hogendoorn,
2018).
Both in developed and emerging
economies, studies have been done on IFRS compliance and VR which produced
empirical evidence on the relationship by comparing IFRS accounting numbers to
those prior to IFRS adoption.(Alade, Olweny &Oluoch, 2017;Elbakry,
Nwachukwu, Abdou& Elshandidy,2016; Adeyemo, Ajibolade, Uwuigbe & Uwuigbe,2017;
Alade, 201; Nijam & Jahfer
2018;Umoren, Akpan & Ekeria, 2018; Odoemelam, Okafor & Ofoegbu,
2019)However, few studies have been undertaken in relation to IFRS 4: Insurance
Contracts and the VR of accounting information. For example, Wu and Hsu (2011)
conducted a study focusing on Taiwan, London, and Euromarkets. Few studies in
Nigeria have studied firms' IFRS 4 compliances, such as (Usman, n.d.) and
(Yusuf, 2014).
Furthermore, results from studies on
the VR of IFRS accounting information remain inconclusive. While some extant
literatures found IFRS-based accounting information to be value relevant
(Alade, 2018; Ionascu, IIonascu, Sacarin & Minu, 2018; Alade et al., 2017;
Alfraih & Alanezi, 2015) others found them not
value relevant such as Umoren et al. (2018).
These studies have also considered
mainly accounting numbers for the purpose of evaluation. With IFRS however, a
multitude of other information are considered relevant for proper decision
making, therefore, the impact of these information need to be examined more in
the literature. Therefore, no study has looked at the VR of IFRS 4 disclosure
requirements as well as how variations in the amount of information disclosed
by different firms affect the VR of the associated accounting numbers.
The importance of evaluating the VR
of accounting information, particularly information required under IFRS 4 which
is particularly peculiar to the industry, cannot be overstated in light of
challenges raised in the sector and gaps observed. The study aims to add to the
body of knowledge on VR by investigating a field that has received very little
attention.
1.3 Research
Questions
According to the stated research
challenge, the specific research questions raised to empirically analyze the VR
of listed insurance companies in Nigeria complying with insurance contracts
disclosure (IFRS 4) include:
i.
To what extent does earnings per share (EPS)
influence the Share Price of insurance companies in Nigeria?
ii.
To what extent does book value per share (BVPS)
influence the Share Price of insurance companies in Nigeria?
iii.
What is the incremental VR of marginal increase
in compliance with IFRS 4 on Earnings Per
Share (EPS)?
iv. What is the incremental VR of marginal increase in compliance
with IFRS 4 on Book
Values Per Share (BVPS)?
v. To
what extent does level of compliance with insurance contracts disclosure
influence the Share Price of insurance companies in Nigeria?
1.4 Objectives of the Study
The main objectives of this study is to examine
the VR of compliance with Insurance Contracts
Disclosure (IFRS 4) of Listed Insurance Firms In
Nigeria. Other Objectives includes;
i. To examine the effect of EPS on the Share Price of
Listed Insurance Firms in
Nigeria.
ii. To examine the effect of BVPS On the
Share Price of listed insurance firms in Nigeria
iii. To
examine the incremental VR of EPS between firms with high and low levels of
compliance with IFRS 4.
iv. To examine the incremental VR of BVPS
between firms with high and low levels of compliance with IFRS 4.
v. To
examine the effect of compliance with Insurance Contracts Disclosure (IFRS 4)
on share price of listed insurance firms in Nigeria.
1.5 Research Hypotheses
Pursuant to the above objectives, the following
hypotheses are formulated in null form:
H01:
|
EPS has no significant
effect on the Share Priceoflisted insurancefirmsin Nigeria
|
H02:
|
BVPS has no significant effect on the Share Priceof listed
insurance firms in
|
|
Nigeria.
|
H03:
|
EPS of listed insurance firms with high compliance with
IFRS 4 is not more value
|
|
relevant than that of firms
with low compliance.
|
H04:
|
BVPS of listedinsurance firms with high compliance with
IFRS 4 is not more value
|
|
relevant than that of firms
with low compliance.
|
H05:
|
Extent of compliance with insurance contracts disclosure
(IFRS 4) has no significant
|
|
effect on Share Price of
listed insurance firms in Nigeria.
|
1.6
|
Scope of the Study
|
The study focused on theVRof
compliance with IFRS 4: Insurance Contracts disclosure among Nigeria‟s listed
insurancefirms. The choice of the domain
is due to the peculiarity of the standard to industry. The study will cover the
period of Nine (9) years starting from 2012- 2020. This period was selected as
it represents the time IFRS 4 was adopted in the Country.
The study will examine the
explanatory powers of accounting numbers; earnings per share, book value per
share and IFRS 4 Disclosures in explaining fluctuation in market price of the
listed insurance firms. The Share Price at the end of March will be used to
represent the value of the listed insurance firms.
1.7 Significance of the Study
Accounting information is important
to a wide variety such as investors, regulators and policy makers, board of
directors, management and so forth. The findings of the study will benefit
investors in the stock market. It will assist in improving their
decision-making tactics for the purpose of investment.
It will also benefit the regulators
Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria and National Insurance Commission. As the research will divulge the scope of
compliance with IFRS 4 and its VR, it will benefit them by providing information
which may serve as a guide to watching out for insurance firms‟ attitude to
adoption of the new IFRS Insurance guidelines taking effect in 2023.
As the research will reveal the
reaction of investors to compliance with IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts disclosure
requirements, the study will be of relevance to management and board of
directors in understanding how informative and relevant their adherence to
disclosure requirements on insurance contracts is to investors and to the value
of their firms.
Also, the study will benefit the
academia. It will form an empirical reference point for future research work on
VR and IFRS disclosures especially on IFRS 4 and other related standards.
Login To Comment