ABSTRACT
This study was conducted to
appraise UNICEF‟s communication approaches for the Infant and Young Child
Feeding (IYCF) programme in Benue state. Child malnutrition has been
a challenging issue, with the IYCF programme deploying several communication
approaches to reduce the level of malnutrition in Nigeria. This research was
anchored on the Health Belief Model and the
Northouse and Northouse Model of health communication, to know the
extent which the communication approaches have been utilized and their
effectiveness. Both qualitative and quantitative method were used to elicit
information from 77 respondents in Otukpo and Makurdi Local Government Area.
The study found that the communication approach made positive impact on
malnutrition level. 74.3% of the respondents across the four communities in the
two Local Government Areas agreed that there was a significant change in the
nutritional status of their children after they participated in the programme.
Findings also showed that economic factors, distance, language of
communication, gender apathy, awareness level and timing are significant
factors limiting the effectiveness of IYCF programme. The involvement of the
participants to give feedback was observed as critical to sustenance of
different communication approaches used for the programme. It is thus recommended
that the use of communication approaches that combine indigenous and
conventional methods should be sustained for more impactful results for future
interventions. Also, there is need to initiate community radio intervention to
give room for local participation and ownership.
Cover page
- - - -
- - - - -
i
Title
page - - - - -
- - - - ii
Declaration--------------------------------------------------------------------- iii
Certification-------------------------------------------------------------------- iv
Dedication----------------------------------------------------------------------- v
Acknowledgements----------------------------------------------------------- vi
Abstract------------------------------------------------------------------------ vii
Table of contents------------------------------------------------------------ viii
CHAPTER ONE: GENERAL INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study - -
- - - - 1
1.2 Statement of the Research problem -
- - - - 5
1.3 Aim and Objectives of the study - -
- - -
5
1.4 Research Questions - -
- - - - -
6
1.5 Justification for the study - -
- - -
6
1.6 Scope of Study - -
- - - - -
7
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEWOF RELATED LITERATURES
AND THEORETICAL
FRAMEWORK
2.1
Introduction - -
- - - - -
- 8
2.2
Communication -
- - - - -
- 8
2.3
Communication Approaches - - -
- - -
10
2.4
Health and Health Communication - -
- - -
18
2.4.1
Health Situation in Nigeria - -
- - - - 22
2.5
Nutrition -
- - - - -
- - 24
2.5.1 Nutritional Practices of Benue State - - -
- - 25
2.6
Empirical Review - -
- - - - -
25
2.7
Theoretical Framework - -
- - - - 29
2.7.1
Health Belief Model - - -
- - - - 29
2.7.2 Northouse and
Northouse Model - - -
- - 32
CHAPTER THREE: METHODOLOGY
3.1
Introduction - - - -
- - - - 31
3.2
Research Design - - - -
- - -
31
3.3
Location of Study - - - -
- - -
32
3.4 Sampling
Technique and Sample Size - - -
-
33
3.5
Instrument for Data Collection - -
- - -
34
3.6
Method of Data Collection - -
- - - - 36
3.7
Validity and Reliability - -
- - - - 37
3.8
Method of Data Analysis - -
- - - - 37
CHAPTER FOUR: DATA PRESENTATION AND
ANALYSIS
4.1
Introduction - -
- - - - -
- 38
4.2
Presentation of Data - - -
- - - - 38
4.2.1 Demographic Data: Age Distribution of
Respondents- - -
39
4.2.2 Distribution of Respondents Based on their
Marital Status - -
40
4.2.3 Household
Size of Respondents- - - -
- -
41
4.2.4 Educational
Level - - - - -
- - 42
4.2.5 Occupation
of Respondents- - - - -
- -
43
4.2.6 Channels used to receive messages on nutrition before the
intervention of IYCF - -
- - - - -
- -
44
4.3 Analysis
of the communication approaches used for the IYCF project- 46
4.4 The
impact the communication approaches on the respondents- - 50
4.5 Challenges of IYCF communication strategy
- - -
-
53
4.6 Ways of Improving the IYCF Programme - - -
-
55
4.7
Discussion of findings - -
- - - - 58
CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY, RECOMMENDATIONS AND
CONCLUSION
5.1
Introduction - - - -
- - - - 66
5.2 Summary of the Study and Key Findings - - -
- - 66
5.3
Recommendations- - -
- - - - -
68
5.4
Conclusion- - - - -
- - - - 69
References - - - - - - - - 72
Appendix I - - - - - - - - 84
Appendix II
Appendix III
Appendix IV
Appendix V
LIST OF TABLES
Table A: Showing some the types of media, their potential for
participation, target audience, advantages and disadvantages - -
- 15
Table B: How
the sample size was achieved for the questionnaire
Administration
- - - - -
- - 34
Table 4.2.1: Age distribution data of respondents from
Makurdi and
Otukpo
LGAs -
- - - - -
- 39
Table 4.2.2: Marital status data of respondents from
Makurdi and
Otukpo
LGAs - - - - - -
- - 40
Table 4.2.3: Household size data of respondents from
Makurdi and Otukpo LGA- 41
Table 4.2.4: Educational data of respondents from
Makurdi and Otukpo LGAs- 42
Table 4.2.5: Occupational
distribution of respondents - - -
-
43
Table
4.2.6: Channels used to receive messages for nutrition before the intervention of the IYCF project - -
- - - 44
Table
4.3.1: Respondent‟s view on the effectiveness of the communication approaches adopted for the IYCF project - -
- - 46
Table
4.4.1: The respondents‟ view on the
impact of the communication
Approach
- -
- - - - -
- 50
Table
4.5.1: Respondents‟ view on
challenges faced in the course of the
Programme - - -
- - - - - 53
CHAPTER ONE
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study
Non-governmental agencies and development
intervention organisations have come to realise the importance of communication
to development (Hybels and Weaver, 1998; Hargie and Dixon, 2004). In this
regard, the United Nations Children‟s Fund (UNICEF) has also fashioned communication
approaches in its development intervention projects to attain sustainability
and impact. How successful these approaches are when deployed is now a subject
for reviews and reassessments. Consequently, this study appraises the UNICEF
communication strategies used in the Infant and Young Child Feeding Practices
(IYCF) in Benue State which was primarily concerned with addressing the issue of
malnutrition.
The IYCF project in each
community required the counsellors to set up a support group that provides
advice to mothers on child care especially during a child‟s first 1000
days-from pregnancy to their second birthday. In addition, the counsellors also
visit each young mother at home to reinforce the messages and work through the
individual household dynamics that may make it difficult for the women to
practice what they learnt (UNICEF, 2015). The project‟s communication
strategies include, Counselling, Information Education and Communication (IEC)
materials, and Radio broadcast.
Over the years, there has been growing
attention on the importance of healthy and nutritious complementary foods
during the first years of a child‟s life (Save the Children,
2012), (UNICEF,
2013). In fact, the guiding principles of Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF)
as delineated by World Health Organization (WHO) state that children should
receive six months of exclusive breastfeeding, after which other food sources
should be introduced to complement the child‟s diet because the mother‟s milk
alone can no longer provide all the required nutrients (WHO, 2013). Also, the
recommended period for complementary feeding is between 6 and 24 months of age.
Research has shown that this period is the most vulnerable stage in a child‟s
development, where incidents of growth faltering, micronutrient deficiencies
and infectious illnesses abound (WHO, 2009).Since this period in a child‟s life
is such a „critical window‟ for healthy, physical and mental development, much
attention goes to promote adequate IYCF practices. However, healthy, physical
and mental development is not the only reason for which complementary foods are
introduced to children. It also serves the purpose of acculturation that is,
introducing gradually a child to the diet and eating habits of its family and
community (Palmer, 2011).
Successful IYCF
interventions rely on behaviour and social change which can largely be reached
through political commitment, adequate resource allocation, capacity
development and effective communication. Current investments in nutrition in
general and IYCF in particular, are very small when compared to the magnitude
of the effects of malnutrition, both as a health and as a social problem.
Although the challenges in the field of health and health communication have
become complex in nature, UNICEF adopted certain communication approaches to
address issues of malnutrition among infants such as one-on-one counselling and
use of IEC materials. The primacy of good nutrition to a child‟s growth and
development demanded a critical appraisal of UNICEF‟s communication interventions
in improving infant and young child feeding if sustainable achievements in
child survival, growth and development are to be attained. This will play a
significant effect on the chances of improving society‟s general development.
In 1996, the World Food
Summit had a structured goal aimed at reducing the number of undernourished
people by 2015 based on the data retrieved in 2007. This data estimated that
the number of undernourished people in developing countries was 824 million in
199092 and in 2003-05, the figure stood at 848 million and reached 923 million
in 2007. This makes Millennium Development Goals (MDG) 4 and 5 that aim at
reducing child mortality and maternal mortality respectively seem very unlikely
to be achieved (UNICEF, 2016). Other data sources estimated that each year
about 1 million Nigerian children die before their fifth birthday and
malnutrition contributes to nearly half of these deaths. This situation is very
alarming and calls for serious concern. Also, the rates of „stunting‟ in
Nigeria have continued to increase for more than a decade. About 2 in 5 Nigerian
children are stunted even with all the interventions and projects put in place
by both the government and international partners (Black et al., 2013).
In 1992, a UNICEF causal
model for under-nutrition gained widespread acceptance for its recognition of
three underlying and immediate causes of malnutrition: food insecurity, poor
health, and inappropriate caring practices (UNICEF, 2012). To address these
immediate causes, the IYCF project was kick started in Benue and other parts of
Nigeria to train women and communities on best practices in raising and caring
for their children. These included an orientation on exclusive breastfeeding,
Key Household Practices, methods of detecting early signs and symptoms of
malnutrition, pneumonia and diarrhoea, maintaining a normal Body Mass Index,
immunisations and sessions on the psycho-social needs of the child to ensure
proper upbringing.
Although Benue state is
described as the „food basket of the nation‟ because of the large availability
of food in the state and large arable land space, statistics have
revealedthat17% of children are„ moderately underweight‟, 7% are „moderately
wasted‟ while 26% are „moderately stunted‟ (Benue State Ministry of Health,
2009). This shows that 50% of children in Benue are deficient in their
nutritional wellbeing. Hence, this poses a great threat to the development of
the state; if half the population of children are malnourished they would turn out
as dependent adults, not able to contribute to the development of the society
while tasking the other half to care for them. Of greater consequence to this
study is the reality that the availability of food is not necessarily a
guarantee for good nutrition. In this regard,communication can play a major
part in adopting healthy nutritional habits.
Howeverin 2015,
the National Population Commission of Nigeria and ICF International, Nigeria
Demographic and Health Survey, estimated that, 23% of children in Benue state
are “stunted”. This data showed that there has been a significant reduction in
the rate of malnutrition after the deployment of the IYCF programme and this
calls for an investigation of the programme to understudy the approaches used,
(NNHS, 2015).
The IYCF project, tagged
“Counsellors Teaching Mothers the Benefits of Locally Grown Foods in Benue” was
initiated in 2011. Since then, the project has been implemented in different
parts of Nigeria such as Yobe, Bauchi, Katsina and Sokoto in order to end
malnutrition in the country. Following this development a report was posted on
UNICEF website on the 9th of August 2013 claiming that:The project
involved the use of counsellors to move health education out of the overwhelmed
health centres and into homes and villages to reverse the problem of stunted-
growth, particularly in rural areas, where nearly half the children are
underweight.
With the emphasis on
communication as an essential component in instilling healthier behaviours, it
would therefore be pertinent to assess the communication approaches deployed by
UNICEF in order to ascertain the level of impact achieved through the IYCF
project. Black (2013) as cited earlier, noted that with all the interventions
deployed to address malnutrition in Nigeria, the rate of stunted growth has
continued to increasefor two decades now. This suggests that, there could be a
gap in the communication approaches adopted and hence the reason for the
increasein malnutrition among Nigerian children. It is on this basis that this
study undertook an appraisal of UNICEF‟s communication approaches with a view
to identify the reasons behind such stagnation in the
development of children.
1.2 Statement of the Research Problem
Despite the increase in projects involving
nutritionaleducation and thelarge span of arable land being used for food
production in Benue state, malnutrition is still on the increase.
Non-governmental agencies, independent cooperatives and the government have, at
different points, embarked on intervention projects to address issues of
malnutrition in Nigeria with little or no success. Issues such as suitability,
funding and staffing among others also affect the course of implementation,
thereby reducing the effect of the project on the beneficiaries, (Federal
Ministry of Health, 2013).Various media channels, strategies and approaches
have also been designed and implemented to tackle the issue of malnutrition but
the outcome has shown that malnutrition is still around.
Current statistics show
that if malnutrition is not reduced it could have a very grievous effect on the
population and this poses a great development challenge to Nigeria as a whole.
There is therefore the need to appraise the communication strategies deployed
in communicating healthy nutritional behaviour so as to identify the reason(s)
for such a developmental gap. This is because communication has come to be seen
as central to behavioural change and development. This study, therefore, appraised
UNICEF‟s communication approaches in the IYCF project in order to measure their
effectivenessin alleviating the challenges of malnutrition among children of
Benue State.
1.3
Aim and Objectives of the Study
The aim of the study is
toappraise the communication strategies used by UNICEF in the IYCF project
geared towards the reduction of malnutrition in Benue State.
The objectives of this study are therefore:
1. To identifythe communication approaches adopted by UNICEF for
the IYCF project.
2. To examine the extent to which these communication approaches
have been utilized to benefit the study locations
3. To evaluate effective ways of communicating nutrition for
healthy living and personal development.
1.4
Research Questions
1. What is the communication approaches used in IYCF project at
Benue State?
2. How successful are these communication approaches in addressing
malnutrition and instigating behavioural change?
3. What communication approaches would be more suitable and
effective in improving healthy living and personal development?
1.6
Justification for Study
Communication is at the
heart of all human endeavours. It has been identified as central to
development. So many communication approaches have been applied to ensure
sustainable development, especially in UNICEF‟s IYCF project yet the problems
still linger. This study is justified as an attempt at appraising communication
approaches with a view to find the reasons behind their inefficiencyin
development interventions.
This research is based in
Benue State which is one of the states in Nigeria with large arable land space
and abundance of food all year round. Despite this, the state has a large
percentage of malnutrition cases. Specifically concerned with nutritional
education and communication approaches, the findings, analysis and
recommendation of this research would assist the government, stakeholdersand
other related bodies to improve in the area of nutritional communication. This
research will generate a process for scholars, students and other researchers,
to improve on the communication approaches available to rid the menace of
malnutrition plaguing the nation.
1.7
Scope of the Study
There are many nutritional
projects in Nigeria today implemented in differentparts of the country.
However, this research is primarily concerned with the UNICEF IYCF project
conducted in Benue state, particularly Northbank and Agan communities inMakurdi
LGA and Otobi and Ogboju communities in Otukpo LGA.This research limits its
scope to a study of the communication approaches of the nutrition projects of
Counsellors Teaching Mothers the Benefits of Locally Grown Foods by UNICEF in
Benue state which took place between
2010 and 2015.
Login To Comment